Used Equipment

Solenoid Valve Selection: Don’t Be Fooled By Flow Rate

Solenoid valve are widely used throughout the chemical processing industries. However, selecting the best valve for a given application can be difficult. Flow rate, a critical parameter for selection, can be calculated using various approaches. However, many of these methods are imprecise or yield non-dimensional results.

Complicating the situation is the fact that there is no single industry-accepted method for calculating gas flow rates for solenoid valves. Some valve manufacturers experiment with multiple formulas to determine which one will result in the most favorable- looking values for their valves. This practice can confuse end users, wasting time and money and compromising safety and efficiency when the wrong valve is specified.

This article summarizes the key issues involved in selecting solenoid valves for chemical processing applications, and discusses their flow properties and the methods most often used to calculate gas flow rate. In addition, it recommends a two-coefficient formula developed by ISA (Instrumentation, Systems and Automation Society), and shows how to use it to determine the best solenoid valve.

Solenoid valves 101
Solenoid valves use electricity to open and close an orifice in the valve body, allowing or preventing the flow of a given medium. In its simplest form, this type of valve is opened and closed by a plunger that is raised and lowered by the energizing and de-energizing of a solenoid. The magnetic field created by the solenoid’s coil turns the plunger’s stop into an electromagnet, attracting and raising the steel plunger. A corresponding spring compresses as the orifice opens. Upon de-energizing, the magnetic field is discontinued and the spring returns, forcing the plunger back onto the orifice and shutting off flow.

It is important to point out that in chemical processing applications, solenoid valves typically do not handle the medium directly. In many cases, the valve acts as a safety shutoff device for a larger system. Performance in this capacity is critical. A valve might be in the system but unused for long periods of time, even up to a year. When it is called upon to shut down the system, it must act immediately and predictably.

Solenoid valves can also be used to control or actuate other processes. For example, they can control the movement of other control devices such as large process valves that manage the application’s media, or energize components such as desiccant dryers or venting systems, which require air pressure.

Let’s review the basics. Flow rate is the quantity of a medium that passes at a given point during a given period of time. It is measured using the term CV, which represents the quantity of water in gallons per minute that will pass through a valve with a 1 psi (pounds per square inch) pressure drop across it. This measure is used to determine a valve’s capacity at higher pressure drops, but also applies to both liquid and gas flows at pressure drops small enough that density changes are negligible.

Another, more accurate term for gas flow is “compressible fluid flow.” Compressibility refers to a gas’ ability to change density with temperature and pressure changes. Flow rates for compressible fluids are significantly more difficult to calculate than those of incompressible fluids, simply because of their properties.

The density of a compressible fluid flow fluctuates a great deal at higher temperatures and, especially, pressures. At lower pressures, the behavior of water, steam or inert gases may be very similar, but it changes wildly for gases when extrapolated to high pressure drops.

In cases in which a flow becomes compressible within the valve, effects might include cavitation, flashing or Mach number effects, making consistency in calculations even more difficult.

Flow path within the valve also can change the CV value (see Fig. 1). A straighter, more direct path means that the medium will have fewer fluid stresses applied to it as it passes through the valve. A tortuous (or convoluted) path will have the opposite effect. In fact, two solenoid valves that are the same in every way except internal construction and flow path can have completely different CV ratings.

Mounting and orientation of the valve, and corresponding gravitational effects, might also affect flow rates for certain solenoid valve types at very low pressure drop conditions.

With all of these potential issues, calculating compressible fluid flow rates for solenoid valves can be tricky. Compounding the confusion is the fact that there are multiple methods by which calculations can be made.

Calculation methods
Today, a few methods can be used to calculate compressible fluid flow rate values for solenoid valves:

Downstream pressure: This method is used by the National Fire Protection Association for pneumatic directional control valves. This equation approximates flow through an ideal nozzle. In the valve industry, it often is used to calculate CV for pneumatic directional control valves. However, it can overestimate the choked flow,”the point where decreases in valve outlet pressure cannot cause flow to increase, as commonly seen in ball, butterfly and solenoid valves.

Average pressure: The mean density equation is derived directly from equations for fluid flow through valves, and, because of its simplicity, is widely used in industry. However, because of the differences between gas and fluid (compressible and incompressible) flows, this equation can significantly overestimate flow for most valve styles, especially at high pressure drops.

Upstream pressure: This equation, like the others, is derived from an equation used for liquid flow. It, therefore, cannot be relied upon to work with choked flow situations. Again, it will overestimate flow for most valve types, especially at high pressure drops, and fail to predict choking.

So, what’s the problem?
These equations are all used extensively by respected organizations and industrial governing bodies. There is nothing inherently wrong about any of them. However, dealing with the specific circumstances of compressible fluid flows and solenoid valves, these equations can provide only a non-dimensional view of flow rate.

So, why isn’t there a single standard? Solenoid valves are used across a large variety of industries, whose end users are concerned about vastly different things.

However, it is clear that derivations of standard equations for incompressible fluid flow cannot reliably be applied to compressible fluid flows. The unpredictable nature of gases and their density changes means these equations can give inaccurate CV values at high pressure drops. Using these equations where they are best suited, at low pressure drops, gives a more precise, if one-dimensional, view of the valve’s capabilities, not ideal for a prospective buyer.

There are other considerations as well. For customers in the chemical processing industries, the CV measurement is typically a benchmark for solenoid valve purchasing. Often, customers familiar with their applications know an approximate CV value needed for a new valve. However, they might be relying on an inaccurate number calculated using any one of the previously discussed methods. A manufacturer should, in this case, work backward with the customer and ask how this estimated CV was determined. If this is the case, the application usually needs to be analyzed again to determine the proper CV so that the manufacturer can apply the correct model valve.

Testing to verify flow rate is always a good idea, especially in chemical processing applications. When a solenoid valve is being used for actuation, the wrong CV can result in vibration or other anomalies in the system. In other cases, a valve may actuate a larger valve irregularly, causing the larger process or control valve to drop too quickly, slowly or forcefully.

Finally, consider the issues that arise for a potential end user trying to choose a new solenoid valve. These equations’ non-dimensional views of valves’ capabilities can result in incorrect information. Manufacturers can test a valve at a given pressure drop to determine the flow rate at a variety of data points, then plug these into any one of the above-mentioned empirical equations of their choosing to determine a coefficient. This coefficient may not describe the valve in a multi-dimensional way. Take the same valve and calculate different coefficients using the different methods and you could get different, less flattering CV values. A lot of calculations are averaged. It even is possible to rerun tests and calculations until the most favorable numbers are gleaned. Figure 2 demonstrates how even valves with the same nominal CV values might actually prove to have very different flow rates. The valves were made by different manufacturers, noted in the graphs by MFR X and MFR Y.

In an ideal world, customers and manufacturers would know that the same flow rate measures are being used everywhere. Until that becomes a reality, ISA’s two-coefficient equation can replace guesswork with certainty, providing a multi-dimensional view of a solenoid valve’s compressible flow rate at a wide range of pressure drops.

About the Author

Ningbo Lida Pneumatic Complete Sets Co.,Ltd. specializing pneumatic components,solenoid valve,air cylinder & pneumatic fittings that these are inexpensive . It has with more than 15years.

Gilmour “Y” Hose Shut-Off Valve, Swivel Nut, large handles for easy on/off. $0.50

Misc use gravel L Gas line parts….fuel sediment bowl holder and shut off valve $0.99

VINTAGE VALVE, SHUT OFF P/N V-200-12A $0.99

Garden Hose Y Connector with Shut Off Valve $0.99

Lot Of 2 Superior Brass Shut Off Valves 3/4″ $0.99

Shut off valve 3/8″I.P. 3/8″ O.D. new in box $0.99

Lot Of 2 Superior Brass Shut Off Valves 3/4″ $0.99

ASCO 2 TWO WAY SHUT-OFF VALVE, NORMALLY CLOSED, 110-120V HIGH VACUUM $0.99

UNIWELD 21085* ENVIROMENTAL SHUTOFF VALVE REPAIR KIT $1.00

1995 Arctic Cat ZR 700, Fuel Shut off valve $1.00

Garden Hose Y Connector with Shut Off Valve $1.00

Orbit Garden Hose Y & Faucet Shut off Valve – Dual Port Water Spigot Splitter $1.53

Orbit 2pk Barbed Drip Irrigation Tubing Shut-off Valve for 1/4″ Micro Tube 69404 $1.53

WATER FED POLE SYSTEM HOSE SHUT OFF VALVE TWIN PACK $1.55

NEW Raindrip 1/4″ Double Barbed Valve 1/4″ Vari-Flow Shut Off Valve $1.55

Green Thumb Poly Shut Off Valve 581734 $1.59

07-125 Fuel Shutoff Valve equal/ Briggs & Stratton 698181 $1.68

Bottle Filler, 3/8in – With Automatic Shutoff Valve $1.75

Orbit Water Faucet Hose Shut off Valve – Dual Port Garden Hoses Y Splitter 69745 $1.75

Orbit Metal Garden Hose Faucet Shut-off Coupling Water Hoses Valve, Spigot 91708 $1.75

M129839 SHIELD, SHUTOFF VALVE, AFC,PTG $1.96

1/4″ SHUT OFF VALVE DIG IRRIGATION PRODUCTS ACCESSORY PACK OF 2 $1.99

STRAIGHT VALVE FULL TURN SHUT OFF NEW IN PACKAGE $1.99

MGB CUT-OFF VALVE BRACKET 1977-1980 GAS SHUT OFF FUEL $2.00

Valterra Hose Double Shut-Off Valve, Plastic Wye A01-0130VP $2.00

BRASS 1/4″ TUBE X 1/8″ PIPE SHUTOFF NEEDLE VALVE 103EF $2.00

Drip Irrigation ½” Barbed Poly Hose Shutoff Valve (1) $2.09

LDR 1/4 in. COMP Brass Shut Off Valve for gas, water, air, grease and oil $2.22

ADEL HYDRAULIC SHUT OFF VALVES 1955 Aviation Print Ad $2.29

Orbit 5 pk 1/4″ Drip Irrigation Tubing Shut-off Valve, Micro Tube Valves – 67404 $2.35

HHO ON/OFF VALVE SHUTOFF DRY CELL HYDROGEN GENERATOR $2.36

RV Fresh Water Hose Shut-Off Valve $2.39

Orbit Ultra light Sweeper Nozzle w/Flow Control & Shutoff Valve – Hose Nozzle $2.41

Eastman Multi Turn Ball Stop Water Shut Off Valve $2.43

ALLSTAR – ALL48011 – RF Brake Shut-Off Valve Decal $2.49

ALLSTAR – ALL48011 – RF Brake Shut-Off Valve Decal $2.49

Gilmour Metal/Water Shut Off Valve 05VGF $2.50

BRASS 1/4″ TUBE X 1/8″ PIPE SHUTOFF NEEDLE VALVE 103EF $2.50

Gilmour 05V Zinc Hose Shut-Off Valve $2.50

Precision Scale HO #3361 Plumbing Shut-Off Valve (Brass $2.50

Bottle Filler, 3/8in – With Automatic Shutoff Valve $2.50

1/4″ VARI-FLOW SHUT OFF VALVE DRIP IRRIGATION sprayer $2.59

Camco Water Tank Filler w/o Shut-Off Valve – 40023 – RV Camper Parts $2.60

Fuel Shutoff Valve – 90 Degree Angel for ¼ Inch Fuel Line – Briggs and Tecumseh $2.79

FUEL SHUT OFF VALVE FITS BRIGGS KOHLER SEARS TORO JOHN DEERE 1/4″ INLET 90D L@@K $2.79

FUEL SHUTOFF VALVE 1/4″ / 90 DEGREE FOR TECUMSEH 35857 $2.89

1/4″ BRASS SHUT OFF VALVE NEW $2.95

(1) 1/2″ PEX x 3/8″ Compression Brass Ball Valve, Shut off Valves Crimp # $2.95

GAS TANK SWITCH SHUTOFF PETCOCK PET COCK CUTOFF VALVE $2.98

BRASS CRANE HIT & MISS STEAM ENGINE SHUT OFF PETCOCK VALVE $2.99

John Deere 420 Tractor Gas Fuel Shut-off Valve $2.99

5841 1/4″ Fuel Shutoff Valve Case Gravely Grasshopper $2.99

5841 1/4″ Fuel Shutoff Valve Excel Hustler Simplicity $2.99

Shut-Off Valve For Soft Rain Water Wand Poly Impact 1PC $2.99

Water Wand Shut-Off Valve Black Poly $2.99

9294 1/4″ 90° Fuel Shutoff Valve Briggs 494769 698181 $2.99

5841 1/4″ Fuel Shutoff Valve Toro Wheel Horse Lawnboy $2.99

5841 1/4″ Fuel Shutoff Valve Pressure Washers Generator $2.99

5841 1/4″ Fuel Shutoff Valve Bad Boy Murray John Deere $2.99

5841 1/4″ Fuel Shutoff Valve Scag Snapper Bobcat Dixon $2.99

5841 1/4″ Fuel Shutoff Valve AYP Yardman Bolens Encore $2.99

5841 1/4″ Fuel Shutoff Valve for Lawnmowers Go-Karts $2.99

5841 1/4″ Fuel Shutoff Valve Kawasaki Kubota Robin $2.99

5841 1/4″ Fuel Shutoff Valve Cub Cadet Dixie Chopper $2.99

5841 1/4″ Fuel Shutoff Valve Sears Craftsman Husqvarna $2.99

9294 1/4″ 90° Fuel Shutoff Valve Tecumseh 35857 $2.99

5841 1/4″ Fuel Shutoff Valve Briggs Kohler Tecumseh $2.99

9294 1/4″ 90° Fuel Shutoff Valve Go-Karts Tillers $2.99

9294 1/4″ 90° Fuel Shutoff Valve Log Splitters $2.99

5841 1/4″ Fuel Shutoff Valve for Snowblowers Tillers $2.99

Non-Rust Zinc Garden Hose Water Shut-Off Valve $2.99

5841 1/4″ Fuel Shutoff Valve MTD Troybilt White Ariens $2.99

AERMACCHI 62096-66P SHUT OFF VALVE GASKET LEGGERO M NOS $3.00

RV CAMPER WATER TANK FILLER W/SHUT OFF VALVE NEW $3.00

Valterra A01-0125VP Valterra Hose Shut-off Valve $3.02

Orbit Metal Hose Y & Water Faucet Shut Off Valves, Hose Splitter Manifold 58061N $3.12

Briggs and Stratton 293934 (691940) SHUT OFF VALVE $3.25

Valterra A01-0130VP Plastic Hose Shut-off Valve $3.44

1/4″ Fuel Shut-Off Valve Straight In-line Cut-Off Gas Petcock Motorcycle Mower $3.45

Green Thumb Zinc Shut Off Valve 581726 $3.49

Fresh Water Y Valve and Shut Off for RV Camper $3.52

Camco’s Taste Pure Plastic Y Valve w/ Shutoff for Hose $3.52

1/4″ JOHN GUEST QUICK CONNECT SHUTOFF BALL VALVE IPS247 $3.54

3/8″ JOHN GUEST QUICK CONNECT SHUTOFF BALL VALVE IPS247 $3.54

1/4″ Quick Connect QC Shut Off Valve John Guest JG Irrigation $3.54

3/8″ Quick Connect QC Shut Off Valve John Guest JG Irrigation $3.54

(1) 1/2″ PEX Brass Ball Valve, Shut off Valves Crimp # $3.55

Camco 20073 Y-Style Shut-Off Valve Plastic Camper $3.63

Camco 40023 Water Tank Filler w/o Shut-Off Valve $3.63

Camco’s Plastic Inline Garden Hose Shutoff Valve $3.72

Camco 20003 Straight Shut-Off Valve Plastic Camper $3.77

Gilmour Hose End Nylon Water Shut-Off Valve 07V-C/07HD $3.78

AB Dick Sucker Tubes w/Shut-Off Valves 18014 $3.80

Princeton Brass PKF3310 3/8 FIP x 3/4 inch compression angle stop shutoff valve $3.87

KB 3/8 FIP x 3/4″ compression angle stop shutoff valve PC finish KF3310 $3.87

Valterra A01-0144VP Hi Flow Shut off Valve $3.89

Yamaha Exciter 570 Gas Tank Petcock Fuel Shut Off Valve $3.89

1/4″ Fuel Shut-Off Valve In-line 90 Cut Off Petcock Mini Bike Motorcycle Gas $3.90

5831 B Frazer Tiller Fuel Strainer Shut Off Valve Nut $3.95

INLINE FUEL SHUTOFF VALVE 698183 494768 BRIGGS DEERE AM107340 SNAPPER TORO 54-31 $3.98